Why I’m Hoping Robert Mueller Finds Nothing

It’s not unreasonable to say that being an outspoken critic of the President has been responsible for what success I’ve had as a writer.

By far my most read essays have been criticisms of Donald Trump. I even wrote a book on the 2016 election about how Donald Trump’s presence in that election affected my opinions and those of the broader electorate. It comes out in May. 

I believe that the movement that elected President Trump represents a toxic shift in American political ideology. It’s a turn away from enlightenment and the western liberal ideals responsible for the embarrassment of abundance that is modern day American life. It’s a turn back towards the ethnocentric nationalism that nearly destroyed human kind in the 20th century.

His attacks on the centuries old institutions of our great nation are tremendously harmful; his gas-lighting of the media; his irrational degradation of anyone that criticizes him; his personal tirades on Twitter hours before America takes military action against a a foreign power are all deeply troubling to me.

I’m no social justice warrior. I wasn’t with her. I didn’t feel the Bern. I’m just not gullible enough to believe the new Trump integrity act or susceptible to the political rot that would have me forget history and lose the understanding of the collective score of things. The last 75 years have been the most peaceful and prosperous in the history of our species. Somehow, some not insignificant portion of America has been sold on the belief that things are so troubled that Donald Trump is the answer. That’s a harmful, delusional idea.

That’s why I want it to end. As soon as possible. In November of 2020. No earlier.

There’s a dangerous game that’s being played right now by the Trump administration’s political opponents. I don’t believe that the investigation into the Trump campaign is a witch hunt. On the contrary, I believe that our democracy was attacked by a foreign power and that an investigation into the role the election’s winning party played in that attack is not only justified but necessary. But the strategy being played by the Trump administration’s political opponents is the same one the Republican political establishment played with Hillary Clinton in 2016.

It’s a loser.

In 2016 the GOP establishment sat back and hoped for a smoking gun in the Benghazi investigation. And when they woke up to the reality that it wasn’t going to happen, they’d already lost their party to Trump-ism. The recent announcement that Paul Ryan will not seek reelection has made it final.

The GOP is Donald Trump. The name on the party is the same. But the people and ideas are not.

Today, Trump’s opposition is doing the same thing Clinton’s did. And it’s not going to end well. We’re a year and a half into Trump’s first term. If Robert Mueller rolled out of bed tomorrow with a smoking gun of criminal evidence against Donald Trump, this still wouldn’t be over.

Donald Trump is never resigning the office of The President of the United States.

As a result, a long and painful process would still have to play out. And only then Donald Trump would potentially go down as the only president in history to be impeached and forced to leave office. That may sound like a good thing to many. But it’s not. If you think the #MAGA crowd is problematic now, wait until we give them even a whiff of Donald Trump the political martyr. Like Obi Wan, if we strike him down, Trump will become more powerful than we can possibly imagine.

And the payoff?

America would have bought herself about a year less of a Trump presidency.

It’s not worth it. Get back to work on building a political strategy that wins in 2020.

The only way America proves that Trump-ism is a speed bump on the highway towards progress, inclusion and prosperity is by rolling right over it and putting its leader in the rearview mirror with the failed one-term presidents of the past.

If we want this movement to die, buhleeeve me we do, the only way it happens is by a resounding defeat at the polls, first in the midterms and again in November of 2020. Trump-ism fades not with the whimper of a legal technicality, but by the thunderous voice of democracy declaring in full throat that Trump-ism was a bad idea; the political version of New Coke.

That’s how it ends.

So if you’re reading this and you have anything to do with the Democratic political machine, instead of combing Twitter with bated breath for the next media nugget about the Mueller investigation to drop, ask yourself a question.

Who’s your candidate?

It better be someone that can beat a Donald Trump in 2020 who is more likely to be exonerated by this investigation than toppled by it. That’s not political folly. It’s just math. And Hope is not a plan.

The ref isn’t going to call the fight.

The American electorate can’t wait for Mueller to do our jobs for us.

3 replies »

  1. All important points. I don’t like reading them, but they are important. And coming from the left, the silver lining seems to be people are fired up. You are so right about Trump the martyr. And how did I miss you announcing your book? The last two years have shook the ground under my feet, I have had to think about things I have just taken for granted. I also find myself being further alienated from the hard left, and the callout/victim culture. I wrote to someone the other day that I think this is one of the first times I have ever had an identity crisis. I don’t know where I am on the playing field. I hold my enlightenment values close, and will continue with direct action kindness, but I do not feel part of a community anymore. I am guessing some on the right feel similarly. Again, I love your writing and am always excited to hear your POV as we come from very different places, but have a lot in common.


  2. I’ll echo a good deal of what Candy had to say and I thank you for your words as well as your service. I’ve read your stufon and off for a while now and they’ve become an important piece of my trying to keep up with the constant breaking news and related insanity. I’d thought about this concept several times and wondered if it was only me who saw how this could all become even worse… thank you.


  3. I agree, although not with the title line. I agree that a Trump impeachment could be the worse thing that could happen. But I wouldn’t say I hope Mueller finds nothing because I think there is something there. I think we should leave whatever findings on the table, along with what has already come out. Yes, strong resistance and dissent, just as we have had to “accept” whatever comes out of the Congress and move on with a positive platform for the Democratic Party. The forces that brought Trump to power benefit from the chaos and disruption of a government that we need to address the many serious issues our country faces.